Home / Should You Buy the Paint Yourself When Hiring a Painter?

Supplying Your Own Paint to a Hired Painter

Once homeowners see the materials line on a painting estimate, some start to wonder whether they could buy the paint themselves. You might have a product you prefer, a store where you have an account, or simply a sense that you would pay less at the counter than the contractor would charge. It is a fair question, and some contractors will agree to it. Before you suggest it, though, it helps to understand what supplying your own paint changes about the job, the price and the responsibility for the result.

How contractors usually handle materials

Most painting contractors buy materials themselves through accounts with paint suppliers. They know the products, they can adjust orders during the job, and the supplier often delivers directly to the site. The materials cost is folded into the estimate, sometimes as a separate line and sometimes as part of a single total. Contractors may add a margin to materials to cover the time spent ordering, picking up, tracking and returning products, and the risk of mistakes.

When you supply paint yourself, you take over that work and that risk.

What you might gain

Control over the product. You choose the exact product line and sheen and know precisely what went on your walls.
Transparency. You see the actual materials cost instead of a figure blended into a total.
Possible savings. Depending on how the contractor prices materials and what access you have to discounts, you may pay less for the paint itself. This is not guaranteed.

What you take on

Quantity

You now need to know how much paint, primer and caulk the job requires. Order too little and the crew stops while someone goes to the store, which costs time and may mean a new batch that differs slightly in color. Order too much and you have unused gallons, some of which may not be returnable once tinted. Ask the contractor for a written materials list with quantities per product and color, and ask whether they will adjust if the list proves short.

Tint consistency

Paint tinted in separate batches can vary slightly. Professionals often combine several gallons of the same color into a larger container before use, a practice called boxing, to even out small differences. If you buy paint in several trips, make sure the store uses the exact same formula each time, and ask the crew to box paint for large areas.

Delivery and timing

The crew needs the right products on site when they start each stage. If materials arrive late, the crew waits, and that time may become a charge. Coordinate delivery with the contractor's schedule.

Responsibility for failure

This is the most important consideration. If a paint job fails early, the question of why becomes central. Was it preparation, application or the product? When the contractor supplied the product, that question usually stays between the contractor and the supplier. When you supplied it, a contractor may reasonably say the product was your choice. Many contractors limit or exclude their workmanship warranty when the homeowner provides materials. Ask how the warranty changes, and get the answer in writing.

Products that fit the job and the region

Paint products are designed for specific surfaces and conditions. Exterior products differ from interior ones, trim enamels differ from wall paints, and primers are chosen for what they cover. In the Los Angeles basin, architectural coatings are regulated for VOC content by the South Coast AQMD, so the product you buy should be compliant for use here. Buying locally usually takes care of this, but it is worth confirming if you buy online or bring products from elsewhere.

Ask the contractor which products they recommend and whether they are comfortable applying the product you have chosen. Some contractors are very familiar with particular lines and know how they behave in heat and sun. They may push back on a product for practical reasons worth hearing.

How it changes the estimate

If you supply materials, ask for a revised estimate that shows labor alone. Compare it against the original estimate minus the cost of the materials you would buy. The difference is what you would actually save, if anything. Remember to include your own time for selecting, buying, transporting and managing materials, and the risk of delays.

Also clarify who supplies the smaller items: caulk, patching compound, sandpaper, tape, plastic, drop cloths, and the containment materials required for lead-safe work on older homes. Some homeowners agree to supply only the finish paint and leave everything else to the contractor. That split is often simpler.

Writing it into the contract

If you go this route, the contract should say clearly:

Which materials you supply and which the contractor supplies.
The product names, colors and quantities you will provide.
When and where materials will be delivered.
What happens if materials run short or arrive late.
How the workmanship warranty applies to owner-supplied materials.
What happens to leftover materials.

Leftover paint and returns

Whoever buys the paint owns the leftovers. If you supply materials, agree with the contractor on what happens to partly used cans at the end of the job. Keeping a labeled quart or gallon of each color is useful for future touch-ups. Unopened, untinted products may be returnable depending on the store, but tinted paint usually is not. Unwanted leftover paint should go to a proper household hazardous waste or paint recycling drop-off, which Los Angeles County and many paint retailers offer, and should never be poured down a drain or into the garbage.

Specialty products

Primers for stains, bonding primers for glossy surfaces, and products for cabinets or floors can be less forgiving than ordinary wall paint. If your job calls for any of these, it is often wiser to let the contractor choose and supply them, since they are the ones who have to make the product work on your surfaces.

A middle ground

Many homeowners find that the best approach is to specify the product in the contract and let the contractor buy it. You get the product you want without taking on quantity, delivery and warranty risk. You can also ask the contractor to show you the paint labels on site so you can confirm what is being used. That gives you most of the control of supplying paint yourself, with little of the downside.